Congressional Debate

CONGRESSIONAL DEBATE

 

1.   Each participant will write a bill or resolution and submit it by the deadline made by the tournament director. A student cannot participate in Congress without submitting a bill or resolution. A student may submit more than one bill or resolution, but must designate one as “primary” and the other as “secondary.”

 

2.   It will be necessary for all students to have knowledge of parliamentary procedure and event rules while competing in Congressional Debate.

 

3.   Each bill or resolution must be written in the appropriate format.

 

4.   Each school that has students in Congress will receive a copy of all bills and resolutions to be debated at least two weeks prior to the tournament.

 

5.   Each school must designate one Individual Events judge to be placed in the Congressional Debate judging pool. The designee should have knowledge of parliamentary procedure and Congress rules. One judge in each session shall also serve as Parliamentarian. There will be a minimum of two judges per session.

 

6.   All debate in Congressional Debate is done via proper parliamentary procedure.

 

7.   There will be a minimum of two Congress sessions at each tournament.

 

8.   A seating chart will be prepared in advance based on the names of students submitting bills and resolutions.

 

9.   At the beginning of each session, the Parliamentarian will conduct an election to select a Presiding Officer who will preside over the Congress session.

 

10. All contestants will be scored by each of the judges based on his or her participation in congress as well as the delivery and effectiveness of his or her speeches.

 

11. Contestants entered in Congress may not enter another event.

 

12. Awards for best speakers in Congressional Debate will be determined by the points given by the judges in each session. The scoring method is the NFL base system found in the NFL Congressional Debate manual.

 

13. Election procedures concerning the Presiding Officer and awards will be conducted by a Parliamentarian and a member of the Executive Committee.

 

14. See WVIFL and NFL  Student Congress Procedures for additional information.

 

15. All forms of plagiarism must be avoided. Any student found guilty of plagiarism will be disqualified in that tournament. A student found guilty of a second infraction in plagiarism will be prohibited from participating in future WVIFL tournaments.

 

To avoid plagiarism, students must bring to the tournament a typed copy of his/her speeches showing documentation in either MLA or APA style, which includes in-text citations and a Works Cited (MLA) or References (APA) page at the end.  The contestant should be ready and able to turn in a copy of speeches to the judge or tournament director if asked.

 

 

 

WVIFL CONGRESSIONAL DEBATE PROCEDURES

 

ORDER OF BUSINESS IN THE SESSION

Call to order

Roll call of members and confirmation of seating chart

Announcements and questions

Election of presiding officer

Setting of the docket

Floor debate on bills and resolutions

Election of best presiding officer

Adjournment

 

PRESIDING OFFICER

The presiding officer be elected secret ballot. The PO will be elected by a simple majority vote. The PO shall follow parliamentary procedure. He or she will consider bills and resolutions in the porder in which they are placed on the docket unless rules are suspended through parliamentary procedure. It is the responsibility of the PO to keep time, recognize speakers, maintain order, and keep record of the number of times each member has spoken. The PO must gavel down a speaker at 3 ¼ minutes. The PO may not relinquish the chair to debate.

 

DEBATE

The author of the bill or resolution shall be recognized to open the debate with and “authorship speech,” but thereafter he or she shall be given no special speaking consideration. The “authorship speech” is to be no more than three minutes in length and should explain why the members of Congress should support the bill or resolution. A mandatory two minutes of questioning by the members will follow the authorship speech. Questions should be brief and to the point. A two minutes questioning period is not applicable to amendment authorship speeches.

 

Members wishing to make a speech following the authorship speech must be recognized by the PO before speaking. Members shall claim the floor only if they wish to speak on the opposite position of the preceding speaker. An affirmative speech must be followed by a negative speech and a negative speech must be followed by and affirmative. Speeches may be made on the same position only if there is no one who wishes to speak in opposition.

 

All speeches are limited to three minutes. There is a mandatory question period after each speech lasting no more than one minute. When a speaker has made three speeches (this does not include questions or motions) he or she may not be called upon during that session by the PO unless no other member wishes to speak.

 

A member may not yield any portion of his or her speaking time to another member except for a question. If a member wishes to ask a questions, he or she should rise and say, “Mister/Madam Speaker (President) will the speaker yield for a question?” The chair then asks the speaker if he or she wishes to yield. If not, the questioner will resume his nor her seat and should not interrupt again. If the speaker yields, ask one question quickly and concisely. A speaker may choose to answer questions only after completing a speech, if there is time remaining.

 

The correct way to obtain the floor is to rise immediately upon conclusion of speaker’s remarks and say, “Mr. (Madam) Speaker (President).” If recognized, the member may then proceed to make a motion or present a speech. Only the member recognized by the PO may speak.

 

Under no circumstances is a member allowed to argue with the PO. If a member believes the PO has made a serious error, he or she can “Rise to a point of Parliamentary Procedure.” The PO will respond by saying, “State your point.” If a member still does not agree with the PO he or she may “Appeal the decision of the chair.” This motion requires a second. The member making the appeal may explain his or her reason. The PO may respond. A vote is then taken and it is the final decision. The Parliamentarian is the final authority on rules, but should only intercede when absolutely necessary. The Parliamentarian should not interfere with or influence the Congress session.

 

The motion for “previous question” should not be overworked. As long as a member has something to say that advances the debate, he or she should be given the opportunity to say it. When no one wishes to speak, a vote should be taken. It is not necessary to “move to previous question” to take a vote.

 

When referring to another participant, use the following titles: “Senator…” or “Representative…”
 

A bill or resolution may be amended. Amendments must be in writing and state exactly the words to be added or stricken out. The amendment is to be given to the Presiding Officer. The PO will, at his or her discretion, and usually – but not exclusively following a negative speech – announce that he or she has an amendment on the floor. The PO will then read the amendment and identify the author. The PO will ask for a second. It may be considered only upon a second of 1/3 of the members. If the amendment does not receive the required second, debate continues with the next appropriate speech. If the amendment is seconded, the author of the amendment is entitled to a three minute speech in favor of the amendment; however, there is no mandatory two minute period of questioning. Debate will then alternate for and against until the amendment is voted on. If passed, debate is now on the amended bill or resolution. If the amendment fails, debate returns to the unamended bill or resolution.

 

What should be written on the amendment form is as follows:

      Author (of the amendment):

      Bill or Resolution #:

      Line (s) affected:

      Wording of the motion:

 

 

 

 

BILLS AND RESOLUTION

 

Bills and resolutions must be submitted in the following form:

 

1. Typed and double-spaced

2. No longer than one page (one-side only)

3. Use between 10-12 font, preferably Times New Roman or Arial style

3. Each line is numbered, not just each section

4. First line of a bill: “Be it Enacted by the Student Congress assembled that…”

5. The first line of a resolution (after each Whereas clause): “Be it Resolved by the Student Congress assembled that…”

 

A bill, if enacted, has the force of law. It tells in an imperative mood what policy is to be adopted, when it is to go into effect, who is to oversee its implementation and enforcement, and what penalties are to be assessed for violations.

 

A resolution is a recommendation of action and has no enforcement or penalty clause. It expresses a conviction or belief and usually centers debate on the broad principles of a concept. It does not carry the force of law.

 

A resolution has whereas clauses, but a bill does not. A bill is written in sections, but a resolution is not. Both should focus on national or state issues of importance.

 

For further clarification, refer to the samples included in this packet.

 

FINAL BALLOTING

 

A total of the judges’ points will determine 1st through 6th place.

 

The members of Congress will vote at the end of the final session to select the Best Presiding Officer.

 

Immediately following the conclusion of the balloting, the results are to be turned in to the Tab Room. NO results are to be discussed with the contestants.

 

PARLIAMENTARY PROCEDURE

 

See attached list of Frequently Used Motions.

A participant may refer to this list while participating in a Congress session.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

SAMPLE BILL AND RESOLUTION

 

 

A Bill Concerning Medical Records of Political Candidates

 

1.         Be it Enacted by the Student Congress assembled that:

2.         Section 1: All candidates for the office of President and Vice-President of the United States 3.     must make their medical records public at the time they announce their candidacies.

4.         Section 2: Every two months after that time until the general election they must re-release

5.         their medical records if any changes have occurred.

6.      Section 3: Any candidates failing to comply with the above section will face a fine of 

7.      $5000.00 for every week records are withheld.

8.         Section 4: The U.S. Department of Justice will enforce this law.

9.         Section 5: This bill will go into effect January 30, 2008.

 

Respectfully submitted,

Name

School

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

A Resolution to Eliminate Politically Correct Language in Colleges

 

1.         Whereas: Restrictions designed to hinder the expression of ideas violates the First 

2.         Amendment to the United States Constitution, and

3.         Whereas: All Americans are entitled to voice their opinions under the Bill of Rights, and

2.      Whereas: College campuses are open forums for the discussion of divergent viewpoints,

3.      Therefore Be it Resolved by the Student Congress assembled that all politically correct

6.         language requirements be eliminated from college campuses and curricula.

     

Respectfully submitted,

 

Name

School